|Anonymous | Login | Signup for a new account||2013-12-07 08:10 CET|
|Main | My View | View Issues | Change Log | Roadmap|
|View Issue Details|
|ID||Project||Category||View Status||Date Submitted||Last Update|
|0002644||Kdenlive||Effects||public||2012-06-12 00:08||2012-06-20 13:49|
|Product Version||Recent git|
|Target Version||Fixed in Version|
|Summary||0002644: Both "White balance" and "3 point balance" cause false colors with default values|
|Description||When adding either the "White balance" or the "3 point balance" effect to a clip, ugly, heavy tinted false colors result with the initial default values (the values also set with "reset effect"), and trying to find parameters that give a reasonable result is impossible.|
With "3 point balance" default values, the red color channel is completely zeroed out.
With "White Balance" default values, grey becomes pink.
(See attached sceen shots.)
|Steps To Reproduce||To reproduce, just add either "white balancing" effect to any clip.|
|Additional Information||I compiled kdenlive myself from the git sources at commit 05a2c84dd45e8797093632e88c1df31f9b0a9ec7 - and most effects I tried worked just fine.|
|Tags||3 point balance, white balance, wrong color|
|Build/Install Method||Manual build from Git|
|Attached Files|| kdenlive_3p_balance.png [^] (1,019,503 bytes) 2012-06-12 00:08|
kdenlive_white_balance.png [^] (1,103,277 bytes) 2012-06-12 00:10
kdenlive_3p_balance_2.png [^] (128,129 bytes) 2012-06-12 00:11
kdenlive_white_balance_2.png [^] (121,389 bytes) 2012-06-12 00:11
|Should be fixed now, thanks|
Thanks j-b-m, I can confirm that the reported issue is fixed as of commit b49e04f016ad4345d292b64aea34eeaa3797ab63.
But one issue (which I assumed to be the same as the reported issue, but apparently isn't) remains with the "3 point balance" effect:
When I pick a color for "black" by clicking first the "color picker" symbol besides it and then into a supposedly black area of the image, all is fine. But if I do the same holding down mouse button 1 and spanning some area supposedly black in the image, bizarre false colors (almost inverted) are the result.
Surprisingly, this odd behaviour does not occur when picking "grey" or "white" reference areas for the same effect, only the "black" picking is affected.
Ok, I checked that and should be fixed now. The "inverted colors" issue happens when you select a "black" color that is lighter than the "grey" color.
The problem was that selecting an average color from a monitor region did not work, it always gave a light grey color whatever the selection was. It should work fine now.
Thanks again, I can confirm that the color picking for the "3 point balance" effect now works (as of commit 4d988e59ca8f3ce0d53250aab4f2f1c6d5ae3b54).
Not really a bug, but one surprising behaviour remained with the color picking: When kdenlive displays a black letterbox frame around a clip (as e.g. to be seen in the attached screen shot kdenlive_3p_balance_2.png, the slim black areas above and below the color gradient image), and one spans that seemingly black area when color-picking, the color resulting from the pick seems to have some unpredictable (non-black) value. It would be less surprising to the user if the color picker just ignored areas outside of the existing image.
|2012-06-12 00:08||karl||New Issue|
|2012-06-12 00:08||karl||File Added: kdenlive_3p_balance.png|
|2012-06-12 00:10||karl||File Added: kdenlive_white_balance.png|
|2012-06-12 00:11||karl||File Added: kdenlive_3p_balance_2.png|
|2012-06-12 00:11||karl||File Added: kdenlive_white_balance_2.png|
|2012-06-12 00:16||karl||Tag Attached: wrong color|
|2012-06-12 00:16||karl||Tag Attached: 3 point balance|
|2012-06-12 00:16||karl||Tag Attached: white balance|
|2012-06-12 17:25||j-b-m||Note Added: 0008125|
|2012-06-12 17:25||j-b-m||Assigned To||=> j-b-m|
|2012-06-12 17:25||j-b-m||Status||new => feedback|
|2012-06-13 22:44||karl||Note Added: 0008127|
|2012-06-13 22:44||karl||Status||feedback => assigned|
|2012-06-20 11:06||j-b-m||Note Added: 0008131|
|2012-06-20 13:49||karl||Note Added: 0008132|
|2012-09-01 20:49||j-b-m||Relationship added||has duplicate 0002663|
|Copyright © 2000 - 2013 MantisBT Team|